Blogs

Donor testimonials are a powerful tool for nonprofits. They provide real human stories that showcase the impact of donations, build trust with potential supporters, and increase fundraising success. And sharing these testimonials pays off—over 70% of people trust a review from a stranger and 90% trust recommendations from a peer. 

But how can you effectively integrate donor stories into your fundraising campaigns? This guide walks you through selecting the right donors, crafting compelling testimonials, and adapting them for different channels while measuring impact.

1. Select the Right Donors

Not all testimonials are created equal; you must choose who you feature carefully to create an effective donor testimonial campaign. Testimonials from the following audiences can make for great testimonials:

• Longtime donors: those who have consistently supported your organization over time.

• Peer-to-peer fundraisers: supporters who have actively recruited others to give.

• Recurring donors: those who donate monthly or annually.

How to Gather Donor Testimonials

Use different methods to collect testimonials that best support your campaigns. For instance, you might leverage:

• Survey responses: Add a “Share Your Story” section to post-donation thank-you emails.

• Personal interviews: Conduct Zoom or in-person interviews to capture emotional stories in detail.

• Video submissions: Encourage donors to submit short clips explaining why they give.

• Social media prompts: Prompt supporters to share testimonials or personal experiences on social media and use campaign-specific hashtags to find them easily.

2. Craft Testimonials That Resonate

A compelling testimonial goes beyond showing support—it tells a story. To maximize impact, testimonials should be focused, concise, specific, and authentic.

To craft an effective testimonial, use the catalyst, action, and impact (CAI) framework:

1. Catalyst: what moved the donor to take action?

2. Action: why did they choose your nonprofit?

3. Impact: how do they feel about their contribution?

Case Study: No Kid Hungry

Here’s how this testimonial for No Kid Hungry fits into the CAI framework for crafting a compelling donor testimonial:

Example: No Kid Hungry – Student Testimonial

• Catalyst: Edwin Lucero’s deep belief that no child should go to bed hungry motivated him to speak up and take action.

• Action: Edwin actively supports No Kid Hungry’s mission by advocating for free meals and spreading awareness.

• Impact: Through his testimony, Edwin emphasizes the life-changing importance of food security and encourages others to take action.

3. Adapt Testimonials for Different Channels

To properly incorporate donor testimonials with your nonprofit’s digital marketing efforts, ensure that you modify them according to the distribution channel. For instance, you might use donor testimonials on the following channels:

• Website & Landing Pages

• Feature testimonials on key donation pages to build trust and increase conversions.

• Create a dedicated “Why Our Donors Give” section on your site where visitors can peruse many different testimonials.

• Email Campaigns

• Insert donor stories in fundraising appeal emails to add authenticity and drive traffic back to your donation page. 

• Use testimonials in donor thank-you emails to reinforce the impact of their gift.

• Social Media

• Post donor testimonials as quotes with engaging graphics (like the aforementioned example from No Kid Hungry).

• Leverage user-generated content with a campaign-specific hashtag.

• Paid Ads

• Include donor stories in Facebook and Google Ads to build social proof.

• A/B test testimonials to see which ones drive the most conversions.

Hypothetical Multi-Channel Testimonial

Let’s take a look at an example of how a fictional nonprofit called Bright Futures could optimize its testimonials across multiple channels. The organization’s mission is to provide scholarships and mentorship for underprivileged students.

1. Website & Landing Pages

• • Testimonial: "I started donating to Bright Futures five years ago, and knowing that my contributions have directly funded the education of five incredible students is deeply fulfilling. Seeing their growth and success reminds me why I continue to give." - [Donor Name]

  • How it's used: Placed on the "Why Our Donors Give" section of the website and the donation page to build trust and inspire new donors.

2. Email Campaigns

• Testimonial: "When I saw how my donation changed a student's future, I knew I had to keep giving. Supporting Bright Futures is the most impactful investment I’ve ever made." - [Donor Name]

• How it's used: Included in new donor welcome emails to build credibility.

3. Social Media

• Testimonial: "Meet [Donor Name]! Thanks to their generosity, five students are now in college pursuing their dreams. They believe education is the key to opportunity—do you? Join them in making a difference. #BrightFutures #WhyIGive"

• How it's used: The post is used on Instagram and Facebook with a static post featuring the testimonial with engaging visuals.

4. Measure the Impact of Donor Testimonials

Tracking the effectiveness of donor testimonials helps refine your strategy for future campaigns. Consider tracking these important metrics to understand the impact of testimonials:

• Conversion rates: How many people who view this testimonial complete the next action (e.g., donating for the first time or signing up for a recurring giving program)?

• Engagement rates: Do posts featuring testimonials get more attention (e.g., shares and comments on social media)?

• Open rates: Do testimonials improve how many users open fundraising emails?

How to Track Impact

• A/B testing: Compare donation pages and emails with and without testimonials to see if testimonials significantly boost results.

• Surveys and feedback forms: Ask donors if testimonials influenced their decision to give in a short post-donation survey.

• Deep research and analytics: Use Google Analytics and UTM parameters to track how pages featuring testimonials perform compared to other pages. 

Start Leveraging Donor Testimonials Today

Remembere what really matters in nonprofit marketing communications: it isn’t what you say about your nonprofit and its missions—it’s what others say about you and the impact you create. 

By integrating testimonials into your campaigns, you’re reinforcing the real-world difference donors make. Start collecting and sharing impactful donor stories today to enhance your fundraising success.